In a bold move, Lee Hsien Yang has publicly objected to the government’s proposal to designate the family home of Singapore’s first prime minister, Lee Kuan Yew, at 38 Oxley Road as a national monument. His concerns, articulated in an open letter to Prime Minister Lawrence Wong, emphasize respect for his father’s declared wishes.
Government Proposal Sparks Controversy
On 3 November 2024, the National Heritage Board (NHB) and the Singapore Land Authority (SLA) announced plans to gazette the site, highlighting its historic significance as a backdrop for pivotal political discussions. The intention is to transform the location into a public space, potentially as a heritage park.
However, Lee Hsien Yang argues that preserving the site contradicts Lee Kuan Yew’s long-standing stance against monuments, stating that his father wished for the house to be demolished. He emphasised this point in his letter:
- "Throughout his life, Lee Kuan Yew was clear and unambiguous that he wanted his home at 38 Oxley Road demolished. He was against any monuments, and this was part of the values he stood for."
- Lee also referred to a line in his father’s will affirming his desire for the property to remain private, exclusively for family descendants.
- He mentioned public opinion polls showing significant support for demolishing the house instead of converting it into a national monument.
Backlash Against the Gazetting
Lee Hsien Yang expressed his disappointment in the letter, suggesting that the move would serve only to dishonor Lee Kuan Yew’s legacy:
"The PAP government can honour Lee Kuan Yew on a matter of deep importance to him, or trample on his wishes and create a monument to that dishonour."
The deadline for submitting formal objections was set for 17 November 2024, after which Acting Minister for Culture, Community and Youth David Neo is bound to consider the feedback before deciding on the preservation order.
Historical Context of the Dispute
Contentions over 38 Oxley Road have evolved significantly since Lee Kuan Yew’s death. The late prime minister had expressed in various statements his desire for the house to be demolished, viewing it not as a relic, but rather a space that should not attract public attention posthumously.
Complications arose following his death, with family members navigating differing interpretations of his wishes. Lee Hsien Yang’s recent objections reflect ongoing tensions within the family concerning the handling of their father’s legacy.
What Happens Next?
As the public awaits the final decision from the authorities, this controversy continues to highlight the delicate balance between preserving historical sites and honoring personal legacies in Singapore.