As the conflict in Gaza escalates, a group of United Nations experts has raised concerns about elements of US President Donald Trump’s peace plan unveiled last week. With violence intensifying, these experts warn that certain aspects of the plan may deepen the oppression of Palestinians.
UN Experts’ Concerns
In a statement released on 3 October 2024, thirty-five UN independent experts described the peace plan as inconsistent with international law. They highlighted several issues, stating:
- Imposing peace at any price risks future injustice and instability.
- The proposed transitional “Board of Peace” is reminiscent of colonial practices.
- This plan could replace Israeli control with US-led occupation.
While they welcomed calls for a ceasefire and no forced displacement from Gaza, they insisted that any peace initiative must be grounded in self-determination and accountability for all parties.
Hamas and the Peace Proposal
In parallel, as Israel’s military forces continued their campaign in Gaza, Hamas signaled its acceptance of certain elements of Trump’s 20-point peace proposal, including:
- A ceasefire and withdrawal of Israeli troops.
- Release of hostages held by both parties.
However, Hamas left unresolved issues regarding disarmament—a primary demand from Israel that complicates potential negotiations.
Ongoing Violence in Gaza
On 5 October 2024, Israeli airstrikes struck residential buildings in Gaza City amid the hopes for a ceasefire. Local reports indicate:
- At least four Palestinians were killed in ongoing attacks.
- The humanitarian situation worsened, with shortages of food and medical supplies.
As civilians grapple with the reality of the conflict, locals question the effectiveness of international diplomacy, with one Gaza resident lamenting, “Where is the truce Trump told us about?”.
The Challenges Ahead
Despite the proposed peace framework, skepticism persists as violence continues unabated. The intricate balance between political demands and humanitarian needs remains a point of contention for many, with both Palestinian and Israeli authorities under immense pressure.