In a significant legal development, a US judge has ruled against Elon Musk’s efforts to transfer a Pennsylvania lawsuit concerning his US$1 million voter prize initiative back to federal court. This decision, issued on 1 November 2024 by US District Judge Gerald Pappert in Philadelphia, comes just days before the crucial US presidential election.
Details of the Lawsuit
The lawsuit, filed by Philadelphia District Attorney Lawrence Krasner on 28 October 2024, seeks to block Musk’s America PAC from awarding substantial cash prizes to registered voters in battleground states. Krasner labelled the giveaway an “illegal lottery”, arguing that it coerces participants into submitting personal information.
What’s at Stake?
- Musk has already awarded US$1 million to 14 participants of his initiative.
- The final prize is set to be drawn on 5 November 2024, the day of the presidential election.
- The lawsuit challenges the legality of the programme, which awards money to those who sign a petition advocating for free speech and gun rights.
Federal and State Legal Implications
Krasner’s legal team argues that Musk’s operation raises significant concerns regarding election interference and free speech. His initiative is reportedly confined to seven key battleground states, including Pennsylvania, Georgia, and Arizona — all pivotal in determining the election outcome.
Furthermore, the US Department of Justice has cautioned Musk’s America PAC that the voter incentive may potentially contravene federal laws prohibiting financial compensation for voter registration. While federal prosecutors have yet to take any public action, the ramifications of this legal tussle could influence voter engagement in these critical areas.
As polls indicate a tight race between former President Donald Trump and Democratic Vice President Kamala Harris, Musk’s political action committee plays a notable role in shaping the outcome of this election.