SINGAPORE – In a heart-wrenching case that gripped the nation, the Court of Appeal upheld a **16-year prison sentence** for a teenager involved in the tragic killing of his schoolmate, Ethan Hun, at River Valley High School on **19 July 2021**. The teen, who cannot be named due to legal restrictions, had appealed for a reduced sentence but was met with disappointment on **23 October 2024**.
The horrific incident occurred when the then-16-year-old attacked 13-year-old Ethan in a school toilet, randomly choosing his victim. Reports indicate that after setting up tape to prevent others from entering, the assailant launched a shocking attack with an axe. He later called the police to report, saying, “I just killed someone. With an axe. I don’t know who. Are you going to send someone or not?” This grotesque act shocked not only the school community but the entire nation.
Mental Health Context
The court’s decision follows a complex interplay of mental health issues and a chilling premeditated plan. Initially charged with murder, the teenager’s charge was downgraded to **culpable homicide** after it was determined that he was suffering from major depressive disorder at the time of the incident.
His lawyer, Mr Sunil Sudheesan, argued during the appeal that the judge placed insufficient emphasis on the teen’s mental health struggles when determining the sentence. Sudheesan explained that his client was in the depths of depression when the irrational plan to harm others took shape, further complicated by exposure to disturbing snuff videos.
Impact of the Sentence
Justice Hoo Sheau Peng, who presided over the case, described the teen’s actions as showing a “chilling degree of premeditation and cold logic.” The sentencing judge noted that the teenager had thoughtfully selected weapons, prepared for the act, and even studied the school’s layout.
There was also poignant testimony from Ethan’s family, who ultimately forgave the assailant. They expressed their grief but insisted on remembering Ethan for his kindness and goodness rather than the tragedy.
Looking Forward
The teen has since reportedly recovered from his depression, remaining in remission since **September 2022**. As the legal proceedings come to a close, this case continues to serve as a stark reminder of the serious implications of mental health issues and the need for support systems.
If you or someone you know is struggling, support is available:
- Samaritans of Singapore Hotline: **1767**
- Institute of Mental Health’s Helpline: **6389 2222**
- Singapore Association for Mental Health Helpline: **1800 283 7019**